Asbestos Trust Fund Damages

What “Damages” Means in an Asbestos Trust Claim

The U.S. Government Accountability Office explains that each asbestos trust has a TDP governing the review, valuation and payment of asbestos personal-injury claims. Those procedures coordinate claim processing, assign values to asbestos-related diseases, establish medical criteria, prescribe review procedures and provide dispute-resolution mechanisms.

For that reason, it is more precise to discuss a trust claim’s value and payment rather than assume that every category of damages available in a lawsuit is separately awarded by a bankruptcy trust.

A claimant must first satisfy the trust’s medical and exposure criteria. If the claim is allowed, its value is determined under the applicable review method before the trust’s payment rules are applied.

Disease Levels and Scheduled Values

Trusts commonly organize compensable asbestos diseases into disease levels. Depending on the trust, those levels can include mesothelioma, lung cancer, other cancers, severe asbestosis and nonmalignant asbestos disease.

GAO found that under Expedited Review, claims satisfying the presumptive medical and exposure criteria are generally assigned a Scheduled Value for the applicable disease level. Scheduled Values are intended to promote relative equity among similarly situated qualifying claimants.

A Scheduled Value is not necessarily the amount a claimant receives. The trust may apply a Payment Percentage and other TDP provisions after the claim is liquidated.

Individual Review and Claim-Specific Factors

Individual Review can provide a more individualized valuation than Expedited Review. GAO reports that an Individual Review claim may receive a value higher or lower than the expedited value.

GAO also found that, depending on the trust’s TDP, Individual Review may consider claimant-specific factors such as dependents and pain and suffering, along with factors related to the claim’s litigation posture if it had been pursued in the tort system.

This does not mean every trust separately awards fixed amounts for pain and suffering, lost wages, medical expenses or other lawsuit damage categories. The governing TDP determines which factors can affect valuation and how they are considered.

Need help now? Call 800.291.0963
Live chat available 24/7, 365 days a year.
Submit Your Case

Payment Percentages and Actual Compensation

GAO explains that most trusts cannot pay the full liquidated value of every claim while preserving enough assets for future claimants. Many therefore establish a Payment Percentage, which is the fraction of a liquidated claim value currently payable under the TDP.

Mathematical illustration only — not a guaranteed payment. If a hypothetical claim were liquidated at $100,000 and the applicable Payment Percentage were 20%, the arithmetic result would be $20,000 before any other trust-specific payment provisions. This example does not represent any particular trust.

Payment Percentages can change. Trustees periodically review assets, expected investment performance, claim statistics and forecasts of future claims. GAO reports that the Trust Advisory Committee and Future Claimants’ Representative generally must consent to changes.

Medical and Exposure Evidence Control Eligibility

Trust compensation begins with eligibility. GAO found that qualifying claims generally include medical records supporting the disease claimed and documented evidence of exposure to asbestos products or operations covered by the trust.

Occupational evidence can include work histories, Social Security records, invoices, employer records and claimant or coworker testimony. The exact evidence required depends on the trust’s TDP.

A serious diagnosis does not by itself establish a claim against every trust. Exposure must also be connected to the company, product, operation or premises for which the particular trust accepts responsibility.

Serious Disease Claims and Payment Priorities

Some TDPs include Claims Payment Ratios that allocate portions of annual payment capacity between more serious and less serious disease categories. GAO explains that these provisions can prioritize malignancies and serious asbestosis so that numerous less serious claims do not consume most available assets.

The ratio differs by trust. It should not be confused with the Payment Percentage. A Claims Payment Ratio can affect how payment capacity is allocated among disease categories, while a Payment Percentage generally determines the fraction of a liquidated claim value that is payable.

Maximum Annual Payment provisions can also limit how much a trust distributes in a year, with some claims carried forward under the TDP when annual limits are reached.

Trust Compensation Versus Lawsuit Damages

Bankruptcy trust compensation and civil lawsuit damages are different. A trust applies administrative valuation rules established in its TDP. A civil lawsuit proceeds against potentially liable defendants under applicable state or federal law.

If litigation reaches trial, the court and factfinder apply the jurisdiction’s rules for liability and damages. Trust compensation already received may also be relevant to offsets or credits against a civil recovery, depending on applicable law.

Therefore, a trust’s Scheduled Value, Average Value or Maximum Value should not be described as equivalent to a jury’s damages award. For a fuller comparison, see How Trust Fund Payouts Compare to Lawsuit Settlements.

Multiple Trusts and Other Compensation Sources

A claimant may potentially qualify for more than one asbestos trust when evidence independently establishes exposure to products or operations associated with multiple reorganized companies.

GAO describes occupational claimants who worked at numerous worksites and shipyards and filed with several trusts whose reorganized companies’ products or operations were identified at those locations.

Claimants may also pursue potentially liable solvent companies through the tort system. Courts may account for compensation already received from trusts or settlements when applying the jurisdiction’s liability and offset rules.

Compensation from one source does not automatically establish entitlement to compensation from another.

Confirmed Primary Sources for Damages Facts

No law-firm or lead-generation website was used as factual authority for this page. Government sources reviewed include:

• U.S. Government Accountability Office report on asbestos injury compensation, TDP valuation, Scheduled Values, Individual Review and Payment Percentages.
• GAO accessible report text describing claimant-specific Individual Review factors, claim payment procedures, Payment Percentages and tort-system offsets.

GAO’s report supports the distinction between trust valuation and civil damages. This page does not assign universal dollar values to pain and suffering, lost wages, medical costs or other damages because the primary sources reviewed do not establish universal asbestos-trust amounts for those categories.

Get Help Reviewing Asbestos Trust Compensation

Call 800.291.0963

Live chat is available 24/7, 365 days a year.

Submit Your Case

Published disease values, Individual Review factors, historical trust payments and Payment Percentages do not guarantee compensation. Eligibility and actual payment depend on qualifying medical and exposure evidence, claim valuation, the responsible trust’s current TDP and individual circumstances. Compensation is not guaranteed.